Man Sparks Family Rift After Refusing to Let Brother Bring Dog on Parents’ Anniversary Trip

A man turns to the Reddit community for advice following a heated family conflict over a seemingly simple vacation rule. He says he never expected his decision to spark such a dramatic divide.

“I’m starting to think I have started a family argument over what I thought was a simple request,” he begins in his post. The issue centers around his younger brother and the Labrador he insists on bringing everywhere.

The man explains that he and his wife had carefully planned a weekend getaway to celebrate their parents’ 50th anniversary. “We booked a country house that could accommodate me, my wife, 2 kids, parents, brother, his wife and kid,” he shares.

As part of the special celebration, they also arranged for a private chef to prepare one evening’s meal. The house, however, comes with a strict “no pets rule,” and the chef specifically asked to work in a pet-free space.

The man assumed this would not be a problem. But his brother quickly pushed back when told the Labrador couldn’t join. “My bro has always been glued to his lab taking her everywhere,” the poster writes. When he broke the news, his brother became upset and compared the dog to his own child.

The younger brother even suggested bending the rules to make it work. “To try and accommodate her he suggested leaving the dog in the car whilst the chef was there and said no one would ever find out,” the man recalls.

The older brother, though, says he needed to shut that idea down immediately. “I tried to shut this down by saying it was against the rules and I don’t want his dog barking or running loose whilst we are trying to relax with the kids.”

He adds that there are also health considerations at play. “My youngest is also a bit fearful of dogs and pet hair can be a bit of a trigger for their asthma,” he explains.

According to him, the conversation escalated quickly from there. “Things got a bit heated and my brother said he’d bring the dog anyway,” he reveals.

At that point, the man admits he lost his patience. “I lost it a bit and said if you can’t do this for a special occasion then maybe you should stay home,” he writes. His brother didn’t take that well and stormed off after the exchange. The next update was even worse: “He’s now told our parents he’s not coming unless the dog [is] allowed.”

The situation has left their parents split in their reactions. “Mom says I’m being too harsh and should ‘work it out’ with the house owner and make arrangements with the chef,” the poster explains.

His father, however, sides with him. “Dad thinks he’s being a bit of a brat and it’s my call since I’m paying for it,” he adds.

Despite standing firm, the man admits he feels conflicted about how everything unfolded. “I feel bad because me and my bro usually get along great, and I want him there for Mom and Dad,” he shares.

In an effort to smooth things over, he even offered to cover pet care for the weekend. “I even offered to cover a dog sitter or a [kennel] for the weekend, but he called that ‘offensive’ and said the dog isn’t ‘just a pet,’ ” he writes.

Now he is left questioning whether he handled things the right way. “Do I try to find a compromise, or is my brother out of line here?” he asks the Reddit community.

One commenter makes it clear they support his decision. “This is a weekend trip you planned. If this was an event specifically for your brother, that’d be one thing,” they write. They also point out that the trip is ultimately meant for the parents, not the dog. “But this is a gift to parents, so they’re the ones you need to accommodate,” the commenter says.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

As the man weighs his options, the core issue remains the same. He wants his brother there, but not at the expense of the house rules, his child’s health or his parents’ anniversary celebration.